Why Australia’s housing shortage is set to get worse
Months ago, in The Australian and across public forums, I warned that the federal government’s May budget tax changes would trigger a catastrophic collapse in new housing supply.
My thesis was straightforward and based on the basic mechanics of property finance and development. By altering negative gearing and capital gains tax (CGT) rules while simultaneously slamming the door on self-managed super fund borrowing, the government was pulling the rug out from under the exact cohort of investors who provide the pre-sales necessary to get residential projects off the ground.
I argued that banks would inevitably tighten their lending criteria, restricting buyers’ ability to transact, while falling house prices would send everyday purchasers into hibernation. Faced with evaporating demand, rising risk and impossible feasibility metrics, builders and developers would simply refuse to take the risk of putting a shovel in the ground.
Many would go broke, severely impacting an industry that is the country’s third-largest employer. Unemployment would rise, and the economy would slow.
Today, barely six months later, the latest industry data and frontline reports prove that every single one of those warnings is playing out in real time across the country. And the evidence of a supply crunch is no longer theoretical. You can see it for yourself in halted cranes and empty display suites from Brisbane to Melbourne.
According to new research from property advisory firm Charter Keck Cramer, apartment towers across Australia are now being built at half the rate local councils are approving them.
In Sydney alone, while more than 44,000 projects have been approved cumulatively by the September quarter, barely more than 4,000 were being marketed. In Melbourne and Brisbane, construction is limping along at roughly a third of the approval rate.
Developers are terrified of launching projects because they can’t achieve the sale prices required to make projects stack up. Without pre-sales, banks won’t release construction funding. So, approved developments remain stuck on the drawing board.
One reported response from architects and developers is to redesign already-approved buildings to make them viable, including reducing the number of floors or apartment sizes, which also shrinks the project size and mitigates risk. Mirvac chairman told shareholders recently that development has become drastically harder and that his teams are knocking back numerous projects that fail to meet strict feasibility hurdles.
The economic toll at the coalface of the detached housing sector is equally grim, confirming my warning that builders would refuse to carry the risk of an unviable market.
Queensland property industry veteran Dan Ahern reportedly works with eighty builders nationwide and has described the sector as in unprecedented free fall.
Following the August ban on self-managed super fund (SMSF) residential property borrowing, his monthly sales fell from thirty to just two. Ahern warns that between thirty and thirty-five per cent of builders could simply vanish, taking with them an entire ecosystem of tradies, private certifiers, suppliers, brokers and conveyancers.
Meanwhile, agent Colliers told media the government vastly underestimated the role of SMSF investors in absorbing off-the-plan stock and that no other buyer cohort is stepping in to replace them. Consequently, builders with sites already underway after earlier pre-sales are now seeing their cash flows dry up, locking up development sites mid-project and laying off staff.
The Housing Industry Association (HIA) says that new home sales have slumped by more than 27 per cent over the past year, with early industry surveys forecasting a 60 per cent drop in new sales next year.
Compounding the paralysis is the buyer hibernation I have long forecast. National property values have already dropped nearly seven per cent since March and anyone will tell you their suburb has fallen even more. This is a steeper fall than Ireland’s notorious housing crash.
Of course, the government is either in denial or cheering behind the cameras. They claim falling prices will help first-home buyers. The only problem with that conclusion is that when borrowing capacity falls further and faster than house prices, houses today are less affordable for buyers than before.
Thanks to government ineptitude, higher interest rates – in response to inflation – have slashed first-home buyers’ borrowing capacity by up to 15 per cent. First-time buyers are actually worse off, investors have been regulated out of existence, and builders are fighting for survival.
Further out, we can easily predict today’s slump will result in a long-term housing shortage that will make it even harder for new buyers when interest rates fall, and this government is evicted.
You can’t tax and regulate your way to housing abundance, and until these destructive measures are reversed, Australia’s housing shortage will deepen.