City Chic Collective – Outperforming in a challenging environment
City Chic Collective (CCX.ASX) provided a better than feared 1H22 trading update highlighting strong sales outperformance against a challenging trading backdrop, plagued by rapidly rising COVID-19 infections and ongoing global supply chain disruptions. Management’s decision to invest in additional inventory ahead of the curve clearly paid off with first half sales growing 50 per cent to $178 million; further evidence of strong strategic execution which remains central to our investment thesis.
Interim margins were impacted by 1Q22 ANZ store closures, recent acquisitions and a normalisation of marketing expenditure, resulting in flat 1H22 earnings. CCX continues to anticipate stronger second half earnings due to the growing contribution from the northern hemisphere operations and assuming ANZ stores remain open. We think the medium-term growth profile looks robust as the company targets a large, underserved global market opportunity with its highly scalable online business model and a net cash balance sheet providing optionality.
Market expectations heading into the release had been rebased materially lower following an earnings downgrade delivered by offshore peer, Torrid Holdings Inc. (CURV.US), earlier in January (the company’s second miss in as many months). CURV, a US-based omni-channel plus-sized focused apparel retailer with around 600 stores and annual sales of c.US$1.3 billion (FY22f), cut 4Q21 sales guidance by 8 per cent to US$300-305 million with EBITDA lowered by 36 per cent to US$23-25 million (causing the stock to plunge 23 per cent). CURV Management attributed the miss to labour challenges at the company’s distribution centre and some stores due to the pandemic.
For the six months to December 2021, CCX’s Americas business grew sales by 62 per cent, significantly outpacing CURV which expects to grow sales by 8 per cent (for the six months to January 2022). We suspect this sales outperformance reflects CCX’s pure online model in the US, a broader customer demographic, a broader product range and better management execution, particularly around stock and supply chain.
There were also market concerns around CCX’s web traffic based on third party data analysis. These look to have been way overblown based on the solid website traffic growth of 22 per cent in 1H22 and strong frequency and basket size improvement implied by the 50 per cent top line growth.
Key details from the CCX trading update (14 January 2022) are as follows:
- 1H22 (unaudited) sales revenue grew 49.8 per cent to $178.3 million (6 per cent ahead of consensus forecasts) with comparable sales growth of 44 per cent;
- Revenue growth was driven by 23 per cent growth in active customers (to 1.316 million), higher purchasing frequency and higher average basket size.
- Website traffic increased 22 per cent to 70.6 million while conversion also improved;
- 1H22 revenue growth was strong in all regions despite well publicised labour shortages and impacts to global logistics and supply chains, as well as government mandated lockdowns during the period.;
- ANZ sales grew 14 per cent to $80.8 million, an impressive result from the company’s more mature segment considering the impacts of store closures during 1Q22. ANZ online sales grew 40 per cent, benefiting from the addition of Avenue’s conservative product stream;
- Americas sales grew 62 per cent to $77.2 million, reflecting strong execution of the company’s strategy to re-engage the significant Avenue customer base (Avenue trading materially above pre-acquisition levels) and the City Chic USA website trading back to historic growth levels;
- EMEA sales of $20.3 million (vs $0.5 million in the prior period), impacted by well flagged supply and logistics challenges;
- 1H22 (unaudited) underlying EBITDA $22.5-23.5 million, broadly flat year on year, impacted by ANZ store closures ($4 million), acquisitions (EMEA generated $20.3 million revenue with EBITDA break-even as the business builds and navigates the supply chain issues) and a normalisation of marketing costs (1H21 marketing costs were cut due to COVID-19 related cost saving measures).
- Ongoing supply chain pressures, driven by freight capacity shortages and delivery delays, will result in higher inventory levels in 1H22 with CCX expecting further build in the second half to secure stock for the Northern Hemisphere summer season and key sales periods; and
- Cash as at 1H22 was $40.5 million with no debt drawn.
The Montgomery Small Companies Fund own shares in City Chic Collective . This article was prepared 19 January 2022 with the information we have today, and our view may change. It does not constitute formal advice or professional investment advice. If you wish to trade City Chic you should seek financial advice.
Dominic Rose is the Portfolio Manager of the Montgomery Small Companies Fund. Dominic joined Montgomery in August 2019 after spending thirteen years specialising in smaller companies in portfolio management and equities research. Most recently, Dominic was a Portfolio Manager and Senior Research Analyst at MHOR Asset Management in Sydney for three years. Prior to this, he ran Deutsche Bank’s Small Caps Equity Research Team in Sydney for six years. He was also previously Head of Research at Foster Stockbroking.
This post was contributed by a representative of Montgomery Investment Management Pty Limited (AFSL No. 354564). The principal purpose of this post is to provide factual information and not provide financial product advice. Additionally, the information provided is not intended to provide any recommendation or opinion about any financial product. Any commentary and statements of opinion however may contain general advice only that is prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial circumstances or needs. Because of this, before acting on any of the information provided, you should always consider its appropriateness in light of your personal objectives, financial circumstances and needs and should consider seeking independent advice from a financial advisor if necessary before making any decisions. This post specifically excludes personal advice.
